The Eucharist in Zanzibar

UPDATED: The ENS story by Bob Williams has more extensive quotations from Archbishop Williams’ sermon, and some details about Bishop Jefferts Scori’s day. The story is beneath the “continue reading” tab.

I won’t be able to tell you how many Primates did not receive Holy Communion at today’s Eucharist in Zanzibar until I have reviewed the videotape. Archbishop Peter Akinola did not attend, so there’s one, and reporters spotted Archbishop Kolini of Rawanda clamping both hands over his mouth and then diving beneath his seat, but its possible that hr thought the chalice contained an especially nasty tasting cough syrup. Just kidding. That’s two.

But what a curious situation when reporters go to Church (okay, curious already, but on to my point) to keep track of who receives and who doesn’t.

Elizabeth Kennedy’s report for the Associated Press focuses on the sermon by Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury. The temptation to read between the lines here is strong, but should probably be resisted:

ZANZIBAR, Tanzania: The spiritual leader of the Anglican Communion on Sunday called for bishops to feel humility before God, as a fierce debate over homosexuality and Scripture threatens to break apart the Christian fellowship.

Leaders of the world’s 77 million Anglicans, in Tanzania for a closed conference that ends Monday, traveled by boat from the mainland for a service at Zanzibar’s Christ Cathedral in this predominantly Muslim archipelago on the Indian Ocean.

“There is one thing that a bishop should say to another bishop,” Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams told the packed Anglican cathedral, as dozens of others listened outside under white tents. “… That I am a great sinner and that Christ is a great savior.”

Katie Nguyen takes a similar tack in her story for Reuters.

Both wire services headline their articles with an emphasis on Williams’ call for “humility.”

In Zanzibar, Anglican Primates join in repentance at former slave market

See realities of suffering, Archbishop of Canterbury says in sermon

By Bob Williams

[ENS, Zanzibar] A slave market whipping post once stood where the high altar now rises inside Zanzibar’s 127-year-old Christ Church Cathedral.

Here the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr. Rowan Williams, opened Eucharist February 18 with prayers asking “forgiveness for the past, mercy for the present, and humility for the future.”

More than 600 people overflowed the historic nave. Some, seeking shade from the equator-hot sun, filled a tented area on the cathedral close, grounds that were until the 19th century a nexus of the Arabian-European-American slave trade.

Fellow Primates — the Anglican Communion’s chief presiding bishops, archbishops and moderators — joined Williams around the copper-and-wood paneled chancel as he asked God to “help us to find hope at times of bondage and fear.”

Gathered in Tanzania for a five-day meeting through February 19, the Primates are expected to close their proceedings with a communiqué addressing topics including a proposed covenant that would ask the 38 autonomous Anglican Provinces to deepen their communion amid differing viewpoints, notably on human sexuality and same-gender relationships. [Related stories are online at]

“Grant that we may be faithful witnesses against violence, hatred and oppression,” Williams prayed, adding later that his own Church of England joins this year in observing the bicentennial of Britain’s abolition of the slave trade — an occasion to be marked in a late-March liturgy in Westminster Abbey.

It was to the Abbey for burial that the body of English medic-explorer David Livingstone was dispatched from Tanzania, carried some miles across the bush, in 1873, the same year English missionaries bought the slave market for the cathedral close. Memorials to Livingstone and his advocacy against slavery grace the nave of Zanzibar’s cathedral.

From its carved pulpit, Williams preached a homily based upon scripture lessons addressing Genesis’s account of the rainbow after Noah’s flood; the “patient, kind” attributes of love as expressed in I Corinthians 13; and Luke’s gospel account of Jesus restoring the sight of the blind man on the road to Jericho.

“Today it is very appropriate to think how God makes us see,” Williams said. “One thing we might reflect upon today is what thing are we blind to — who is it now whose suffering we cannot see, we cannot understand.

“In some societies it may be women, the elderly, or children,” he said. In others, “it may be minorities of one kind or another…. It is the case in our wealthy countries that we don’t see the realities of suffering in other parts of the world.”

These international connections were underscored at the service’s conclusion when the Archbishop installed Ugandan-born Hellen Wangusa as Anglican Observer at the United Nations.

[Full text of Williams’s sermon will be available at]

God’s love helps believers see “who we really are” … and “truly because of that we see others in new ways. … So we begin to be able to set about the task of setting others free… the chains, the shackles of our own fears fall away.”

Williams cited the conclusion of hymn writer-priest John Wesley, who said near the end of his life, “I remember two things: that I am a great sinner, and Jesus is a great Savior.”

The congregation had earlier sung Wesley’s classic “Amazing Grace” as part of its “Act of Commemoration, Reparation, Hope” repenting the evils of slavery.

Hymns and prayers alternated between Swahili and English during the liturgy, with loudspeaker calls to prayer from the neighboring mosque occasionally overheard between organ strains.

Most Zanzibaris are Muslim, dating from when the island was colonized and under the rule of Oman’s Sultan before becoming a British Protectorate. In 1964, Zanzibar and the mainland Tanganyika were joined into the united nation of Tanzania.

Welcoming all to the cathedral, Tanzania’s Archbishop Donald Mtetemela celebrated the Eucharist in Swahili and brought greetings from his host Province, which includes 21 dioceses.

Provincial officials joined in presenting gifts to all of the visiting Primates, including Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori of the Episcopal Church “in the United States and 15 other nations.”

After the service — and the Primates’ seaside-hotel luncheon with Zanzibar’s President Amani Abeid Karume — Jefferts Schori returned to the cathedral’s chancel for several moments of reflection at the high altar.

There she had been among the Communion’s 13 newest Primates seated in choir stalls facing the congregation. Seated on the chancel steps were other more senior Primates, except Nigeria’s Peter Akinola, who absented himself from the morning’s service — and the two-hour Indian Ocean boat trips to and from Dar es Salaam.

For his part, Uganda’s Archbishop Henry Orombi — although he opposes other provinces’ inclusion of gay and lesbian Christians — exchanged the peace by cordially shaking hands with several Primates, including Jefferts Schori.

Returning through the cathedral’s traditionally carved Zanzibar doors, the Presiding Bishop was met by cathedral volunteers who took pride in showing her the high altar’s mosaic of Christ’s crucifixion and resurrection.

“This church is seen as God’s intervention in human affairs through men and women of good will,” notes diocesan secretary Nuhu J. Sallanya, writing about the cathedral. “The place of horror and despair has been transformed” into an “area of worship and praise.”

— Canon Robert Williams, the Episcopal Church’s director of communication, is reporting for

ENS from Zanzibar.

Past Posts